Did you watch Mackenzie Phillips on Oprah? I LOVED, LOVED, LOVED ”One Day at a Time” while I was growing up. And while I was more of a Valerie Bertinelli fan, I definitely liked Mackenzie. In other words, I was glued to the TV screen when she pulled up a seat next to The O.
Hearing Mackenzie’s story about her father teaching her to shoot up, use cocaine and roll joints was heartbreaking. All that boundary-crossing drug use apparently carried over in even darker ways. She said she remembers a drug-crazed night that ended with her blacking out. She came to with her dad on top of her. And then there were other nights when she woke up with her pants down around her ankles and her dad asleep on the bed next to her. (I know some people have called her a liar, but I believe her.)
But then here’s the thing — somewhere along the way, and Oprah didn’t really explore this fully, IMHO, these sexual assaults transformed into a consentual sexual relationship that apparently went on for 10 or so years. So, how did it get from rape or black-out sex to consensual sex? Why are those details being ignored? Was there hand holding? Nuzzling? Pillow Talk? Well, we know there was pillow talk because Mackenzie said that at one point her father discussed the possibility of the two of them running off someplace like Fiji where they could live together openly. And that is the moment that Mackenzie says she fully snaps to the reality of the situation: She says her father’s attempt to romanticize this sick relationship pushed her over the edge. She realizes how wrong it all is, and breaks it off.
Unfortunately, Mackenzie’s interview with Oprah came across as staged everytime she tried to make this about a bigger group of people, when she tried to say something along the lines of “I know I am not the only one, and I want to give voice to all the other victims out there” blah blah blah.
Mackenzie keeps calling herself an “incest victim” but I think there is a big difference between a six-year-old boy being sexually abused by a relative and a 30-year-old woman choosing to have sex with her father. Where is the personal responsibility for that? Mackenzie says her history of drug use and emotional neglect growing up led her to make this unfortunate choice, and that is no doubt true. But positioning herself as an “incest victim” because of the consensual affair she carried on with her father does a disservice to victims out there who played no role whatsoever in their abuse.
Mackenzie may think she is giving them a voice, but in the end she may be lending fuel to those who would doubt a child’s claim of abuse.
What do you think? Am I being too hard on her? I don’t mean to be. I think she is very troubled, and very brave, and still very much in denial. I hope she is able to get her act together and revive her career.
Complete and utter aside: Check out Tamerlane Phillip’s comments about his half-sister’s claims about their dad in this HuffingtonPost story.






